This is the official blog of the Exploring Culture and Religion FIG #85 at Mizzou. We'll be using this site during the course of our Fall class to go in depth on some topics related to, of course, culture and religion.
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Religion and Generation Me
By going more in-depth with religion in her book, Twenge would not have had as strong of an argument for how materialistic and self-obsessed our generation has become. In general, religion and religious communities provide an opportunity for reflection and how to improve our lives and the lives of others. While the lack of religion in her book was not blatantly obvious, once pointed out, it seems to weaken her theory somewhat. I don’t think a section on religion could have been worded in any way to support the claim to the “me” aspect of our generation. If our generation is supposedly self-centered and materialistic, how could she explain the religious communities where people work to help and support each other? The only other reason I can think of for why she would have left religion out of her book would be in order to leave it open to interpretation and have people come up with their own ideas of how religion affects our generation.
Twenge was left with no choice
“Melissa, 20, who says, ‘I couldn’t care less how I am viewed by society. I live my life according to the morals, views, and standards that I create.”
I think that religion has most definitely effected my GenMe life and can't say I know someone who hasn't been in some way touched by religion. I think the true reason that Jean Twenge did not include religion in her book is because the lines of religion are no longer clearly drawn with GenMe. She couldn't give a survey to show the effects of religion because it is to all-encompassing to measure. Although some neighborhood We are no longer defined by which religion we are and how much we attend service. We are consistently being effected by a multitude of religions through all our interactions with those of a different religion than our own. Which has created a world of ProChoice-Catholic and bacon-eating-Jews. A survey could never fully measure the effects a multitude of religions has on a
This attitude is not uncommon among Gen Me. I also, believe I live my life according to the morals, views, and standards I create. Simultaneously, I am a practicing Roman Catholic.
Many older Catholics would see these two ideas as incompatible but I have been able to find common ground through the Roman Catholic's support of conscientious objections through informed dissent. Informed consent although completely supported by the church in writing is often brushed over by popular lectures and preaching and I acknowledge that if I had not gone to a Catholic high school I may be completely unaware of this teaching completely even though I attend a weekly service.
It doesn't take a genius to guess why the Catholic church doesn't advertise the “disagreement clause “within Catholicism. Although it does make the religion seem much more inviting. Even teachers at my Catholic school would admit to informed dissent on issues such as gay acceptance, gay marriage, cohabitation, and other issues. GenMe could clearly see the individual attitude in this kind of religious “adherence.” Some will judge and call this being a “Cafeteria Catholic” because you are only taking what you want from Church doctrine and leaving the teachings that might be more difficult- you know the love your enemies kind of things. GenMe has come into a world where your religion can be customized just like the playlists
Like myself, many "GenMe"ers have adopted this new definition of what religion is or can be, across all denominations. Possibly the best examples of religion with out rules is Non-denominational Christians. Non-denominational Christians emphasize scriptural and personal conscience. They rely little on tradition or others opinions in regards to their church or faith. All Non-denominational Christian communities are different because their practices are mostly determined by their members and their members personal interpretations of the bible. If GenMe was embodied in a religion Non-denominational Christian would have to be considered.
Overall I think Jean Twenge didn't choose to not include religion. She never had the option to begin with. There is no way she could truly determine religions effects on anyone. Would Jean Twenge's survey have asked it's participants “Have any of your opinions changed about any modern issue because of a friend or acquaintance of a differing religion than your own?” The question is so broad that all people, if not an outrageous majority, would need to answer yes after thoughtful consideration of the question. Therefore religion surely effects GenMe more than can be measured, but it does not define us because most definitive lines in religion are no longer drawing boundaries that were former held so dear.
Generation Me
Generation Me
Why did Jean Twenge leave religion out of her book, Generation Me? In my opinion I think it’s because the main focus was age. Generation Me was described throughout the book mainly from information based on age. Although age is the main factor, Jean Twenge does touch on other ideas as well. For example, one chapter talks about and is titled “The Equality Revolution: Minorities, Women, and Gays and Lesbians”. Twenge discusses age, race, gender, and sexual orientation. It does seem strange that she talks about all these topics and she somehow leaves religion out. However, I don’t think its absence really affected the book. Today’s generation is not like generations in the past. Our education is no longer associated with the church (in some cases it is, like certain private schools… but still, that’s no longer the norm). School is now, for the most part, separated from church, and most GenMe’s don’t attend church or any other kind of religious services. Because of this, I think it’s ok that Twenge left religion out of the book, because it doesn’t really effect Generation Me. However, it could have been interesting to know how GenMe’s parents’ religions could have an effect on them and how they were brought up.
Generation Me
Gen Me & No Religion
The book “Generation Me” by Jean Twenge did not include religion, which I think is the downfall of this book. There were many true views that Jean stated in her book, but I believe religion plays a large role in our generation and in past generations. To me this book was all about comparison. In some parts Jean makes it seem like our generation is not what it should be. For example she says “ ‘[S]tudents learn that they do not need to respect their teachers or even earn their grades, so they begin to believe that they are entitled to grades, respect, or anything else … just for asking.’ I do not think it is just our generation who acts this way. Most people want respect and some think they deserve it, but I don’t think we assume we have respect. Our generation is more accepting; we try our best to gain respect. Working to gain a persons respect takes time and is totally different than asking for respect. Jean Twenge says,” Some teens find their experiences at odds with their religious upbringing. For many, this means that they see gays as sinners, and/or believe that gays can change to be straight. Others find themselves questioning their beliefs.” 9p. 209). This relates to religion because in some religions they think gay people are bad. Our generation should not feel ashamed or uncomfortable for what we believe or what we do.
Jean Twenge points out that our generation doesn’t care how others perceive us. We do care, we just have been taught to be individuals. Religion plays into this topic because as individuals we believe what we want not what we are told. If our parents are Catholic, that doesn’t necessarily mean we need to follow their religious views. If Jean included religion there would be more substance to her views. The lack of religion does alter my opinion of the book. Even though our generation may decide not to stick with our family’s religion it is still a large part of who we are and how we act. Today many parents take a back seat on MAKING their children believe in a certain religion. Adding this to the book can show the different communication and values our generation has. I would want to add religion to the entire book, but one specific place would be chapter 6. In this chapter they talk about our generations views on premarital sex. Some religions view premarital sex as a sin and that couples should wait till they are in a married committed relationship. It may be controversial to add religious views on sex to the book, but I feel as though Jean just leaves out a big chunk of what really matters. Jean Twenge may have left out religion so she didn’t have to deal with the good and bad comments people have about her book, but like i stated earlier it made the book boring. Despite the lack of religion I think half of the stuff Jean talked about it just bashing our generation and doesn’t say much about previous generations.
Generation Me and Religion
I think the reason she didn’t include religion in the book is because throughout the book she is talking about individuality. Since religion is a very controversial topic and there are so many different religions in our society it would be hard to include each of the religious views. I think Jean Twenge’s true purpose of writing her book was to show how our generation is about individuality and to help today’s society discover who they really are. The lack of religion in the book didn’t change my opinion because she did make a point to mention religion in our society and how it is less likely for us to go to church and pray. She says “GenMe is also less willing to follow rules of organized religion” (pg34). “Our generation would rather do what they wanted than to join a group or go to church” (pg35). Religion, in general, tends to have a way of making people conform to the ways of the church which takes way from Dr. Jean Twenge purpose of Generation Me.
If I had included a section of religion I would include the topic of sub staining abstinence until the point of marriage. As Dr. Jean Twenge mentioned in her book, our ideals of what is right and wrong morally have substantially changed throughout the years. “In the late 1950’s, only 30 percent of young people approved of sex before marriage, now 75 percent approve” (pg163). With the addition of this section in Dr. Jean Twenge’s book, we could have compared how much of an influence religion has on this topic. With young people’s religious views loosing importance, we see many more of what used to be seen as “sinful” actions becoming more of a part of everyday life.
As we have seen from Dr. Jean Twenge’s book, she states that the actions of our young society are declining as a whole. The lack of religion and the lessoning of morals lead us inevitably to the point where we no longer know the difference between what is right and wrong.
Gen Me blog
Twenge’s Generation Me, a highly controversial book in my opinion, can have many readers guessing her intentions for writing this book. Is she trying to help her targeted generation by pointing out their deep flaws, or is she aggravating many people. From what I have grown up around, some of what Twenge points out may be true but it does not truthfully represent my generation. Twenge continuously repeats herself when she should have taken to the time to acknowledge the other half of the generation she left out. By dismissing the other half and brushing over religion, Twenge seems ignorant and self centered around her own theme.
On pages 34-36 Twenge lightly touches on Religion, in my opinion only to say that she did to complete her book, but barely going into depth. She leaves out factors such as the many religions that exist that people can conform to and/or the many reason’s why Gen Me’s attendance to religious services has dropped. For many Gen Me’s that are discovering new faiths to believe in, they may be un known to do research on or may not require physical attending to a sacred church, mosque, etc like other religions do. Or perhaps their attendance is low because their parents work on Sunday’s and they don’t have a ride, or their busy doing community service projects, sports, and other activities. Times are changing and Sunday’s are no longer everyone’s day off. Businesses are open, people are putting in the extra hours and Sunday is just another day of the week to advance.
Including religion could have either supported or contrasted with Twenge’s theme. If research was done and she found that Gen Me’s belief in religion had decreased, that would have supported her idea in a sense that Gen Me was much more focused on their own independent power that they didn’t need any spiritual connection. On the other hand, if research was done and studies had proven otherwise, Twenge’s theme would have been disrupted. With so many religions and other faiths in the United States alone, time to do research may have taken a while and Twenge was probably too lazy and scared of finding out a truth that may have conflicted with her book.
Dismissing the subject of religion didn’t hurt the point she was trying to make but it left big gap. This gap includes the many Gen Me’s whom she decided to leave out of the book, the readers that are the total opposite of her stereotypical Gen Me. In my own opinion, Twenge decided to write a book criticizing Gen Me for their self centered personals and carelessness but left out why Gen Me’s are the way they are. Advances in technology, the spiraling economy, and competitiveness in today’s society are all factors that can be the cause of Gen Me’s personality. This book may be helpful and eye opening to the Gen Me’s she’s referring to, but to the Gen Me’s she left out, it’s offensive, unfair, and ignorant.
Monday, August 30, 2010
Religion and Generation Me
This book was her thoughts. No one can possibly know what everybody else thinks. If I were to include a section on religion in "Generation Me," I would have stated that the beliefs of different types of religion and what beliefs are within that religion will affect the way that a person thinks and views the world around them. Her thoughts are her thoughts and these are mine. Everyone thinks differently to a certain extent, making them a complete individual.
Sunday, August 29, 2010
I believe that Jean Twenge made some valid and some invalid points in her book, Generation Me. One of her valid points was when she noted that today's youth is more accepting towards people of different races, cultures, and sexual orientation, but this positive aspect only took up a small portion of the book. In my opinion, she focused most of her writing on a cliché look at our generation. With all of this said, I think she could have focused less on repeating herself and more on other topics, such as religion.
Twenge believes this generation is more accepting of differences, which seems to be one of the few positive things going for it. She discusses how today’s youth doesn’t judge homosexuals nearly as much as adolescents have in the past. Homosexuality is not looked too highly upon by some religions, such as Catholicism. Personally, I think it would have been interesting to see her elaborate on her view of gay marriage and what today’s generation is doing in order to legalize it or keep it illegalized.
There are a few instances in the book in which Twenge mentions aspects of religion. For instance, she writes, “In case you haven’t heard, ‘hooking up’ has replaced dating among many young people…” “…hookups can range from ‘making out to full-on sex’ but are most distinguished by being ‘between two people who don’t necessarily have any foreseeable future or even a hint of commitment”(p.159) It seems in this quotation that she believes sex should only be for married couples, which is a religious belief. She then uses a quote on premarital sex from a nineteen-year-old girl Felicita: “I strongly disagree with people who say it is not morally correct to have sex before marriage. Marriage is a promise, but all promises can be broken. Marriage should not be the reason why someone chooses to have sex—love should be” (p. 164). In this way she discreetly mentions religion because marriage is a religious sacrament and premarital sex is considered a sin.
Another point that Twenge makes that could have been related to religion is when she talks about how this generation is a great deal more self-reliant than previous generations and how parents don’t have as much control over today’s youth. With this point noted, it is easier for kids to proclaim their religion, whether it is the same religion as their parents or not.
Lastly, I would have liked to see Twenge relate depression to spirituality. She often notes that today’s youth is more depressed than previous generations. Prayer, going to church, meditation, or any other spiritual practice might not cure depression, but it could be a good reflection time for a depressed adolescent. This reflection time could be crucial in helping a person discovering himself or herself, which could pull that person gradually out of the depressive state.
If I were to discuss religion in this book, I would have related some of the core subjects with religion.
Saturday, August 28, 2010
Generation Me & Religion
There are so many types of religions in the world, with so many different beliefs, but they all have one thing in common: Faith. You have to have faith in yourself and the God (or gods) you believe in. If you want to be an astronaut, you have to have faith you can make it through all the schooling, training, and other specialized things astronauts have to do to become one of the elite few. But if you have faith in yourself you can do anything. If you are religious and have faith in Your Almighty, you would have faith that what you want to be and to happen with your life will happen.
According to Dr. Twenge, our generation is too self centered and too individualistic to accomplish any of our goals. Is that correct? Personally I don’t think so. I believe things are meant to happen because that’s the way God wants them to. Some people think everything is a coincidence, which is totally fine, everyone is entitled to their belief, there just isn’t a lot of faith in a higher power. So if Dr. Twenge really had added religion to her book, she would have had to contradict herself. She couldn’t have said it’s every man for himself in this generation and none of their dreams will come true, because if you have faith, then you don’t think about the things that might not happen, you think of the things that hopefully will. Dr. Twenge has no faith in our generation. Honestly, it sounded to me she thought our generation is a bunch of screw ups that she’ll have to deal with. But hey, I guess that’s her problem.
Taking religion out of the picture was a way to say this generation has to think for themselves and decide for themselves, which is exactly the point she makes throughout the book. So not adding religion into her book really emphasized her point and made it seem legitimate.
Friday, August 27, 2010
GenMe FIG Blog
To explain these points, the other two questions must be addressed. The prompt asks me to answer how I would have explained the topic of religion in regards to GenMe and what I would have discussed. The response is simple: I would have addressed the topic in a less condescending light and would have discussed not only the fact that attendance in religious services is dropping, but also why. The why in this situation is the key. A drop in attendance does not mean that GenMe is less religious as the author seems to imply, but it might instead mean that people in this generation are taking up religion on their own. It would seem an obvious connection noting that Twenge's original thesis of GenMe's individuality, but instead she moves through the topic of religion quickly, without ever noting that religious practice may not be on the downturn, only organized services are. Perhaps my viewpoint on the topic is decidedly swayed being that I hail from a strong hold in Bible Belt country, but it seems to me that religion is alive and well today, regardless of dropping numbers in attendance. Once more, it seems that the author has missed the point on an extremely important topic in modern culture.
Questioning What Our Parents Believe
Thursday, August 26, 2010
Generation Me Post
Wednesday, August 25, 2010
GenMe Helpful Quotes
Friday, August 20, 2010
Generation Me Response
Why, in your opinion, did Jean Twenge not include religion in her topics? How did the lack of religion affect the book? If you had included a section on religion, how would you have addressed the topic in terms of Generation Me? What might you have talked about?